Blog

Confessions of Reformed DIY SOC Builders

Build vs buy AI SOC: five lessons from teams that built their own, what tokens, testing and upkeep really cost, and why they came back to buy.

Build vs buy AI SOC: 5 lessons learned from teams that attempted to build their own and came back to buy

Key Insights

  • An early triage win breeds overconfidence and an unrealistic roadmap.
  • Laptop builds run into trouble with model changes, alert floods and governance.
  • Teams budget for tokens and underestimate testing.
  • Building for unique alerts rarely got teams the depth they wanted.
  • The “this time it’s different” argument was made about open source too.

Over the past few months, we’ve noticed a lot of familiar faces in our conversations. Teams that tried building their own AI SOC are coming back to talk to us a few months later. We’ve pulled together what they learned, which any team who’s thinking of building vs buying should consider before starting or scaling their project.

1. They Almost Became a Vendor

Most of these builds started small and worked. A team builds an MVP for Tier 1 triage, and within a few weeks it’s closing routine alerts faster than anyone expected. Then a roadmap shows up. A triage tool sitting on its own falls behind fast, since advanced commercial platforms feed every investigation into detection engineering, threat intel, hunting and response. So, the questions start. Can ours tune detections? Can it hunt? Can it take response actions safely?

Every yes means another discipline to staff, and before long the team is running a product with releases, bugs and a support queue. We know the pattern because we’ve lived it. We’ve spent the last few years building and scaling CognitiveSOC™, an agentic AI SOC platform enterprises can trust, and we keep prioritizing feedback from the market and our customers. That’s taken us from triage and investigation to a full lifecycle platform that also includes threat hunting, detection engineering, threat intelligence, and response. With a homegrown build, the story usually goes differently. It worked until the data grew, the feature requests piled up and someone had to own fixing it.

Build out detection engineering, hunting, response and threat intel on top of an AI SOC and you’re basically founding a company, a SOC vendor with one customer.

2. They Built It on a Laptop

A lot of these projects started on someone’s laptop, in a developer’s terminal or a Claude Code session. That’s fine for proving an idea. It doesn’t hold up once real volume arrives. A SOC needs this running in the cloud, handling tens or hundreds of thousands of events a day, and coping when a flood hits and 5,000 alerts land at once. Then there’s everything around the agent itself: how its memory and context are managed, which environments it runs in, what guardrails it has and who governs it. When an auditor asks why an alert was closed, you have to be able to trace and audit the decision and know whether the system is actually doing good work. A build sitting on one person’s machine usually can’t answer any of that, and it won’t meet an enterprise security standard.

3. Testing Was the Cost Nobody Planned For

Tokens were the line on the bill everyone could plan for. At enterprise volumes, teams tell us they’re spending $100,000 to $250,000 a month, and the builds we hear about average around five engineers who know how to build with AI. One security leader told us he was at $250,000 a month with five people on it, which adds up to millions a year. Then there’s the maintenance nobody budgets for: switching models, updating the LLM gateway and the agent framework, keeping the UI usable. Testing is where the plans really fell short. The same alert needs the same careful verdict before and after every one of those changes. That means rerunning large sets of past investigations each time, which adds five to six figures a month in testing alone. Tokens are easy to forecast. Testing is what tells you whether you can trust the output.

4. They Started for the Wrong Reason

A lot of builds start from the belief that nothing on the market will fit your environment the way your own team can. Some teams were even advised to buy for routine alerts and build for whatever is unique. What they found is that their builds handled the common cases, mostly by summarising and triaging them. That helped with volume, but the depth they needed for the unique alerts wasn’t there. The unique alerts still needed someone to work out what happened, the root cause and the blast radius, and as one large service provider put it to us, filtering noise was never their problem.

Most AI SOC platforms cover a narrow set of use cases. Conifers investigates 100% of alerts in depth, with a company’s own context, across any use case, and shows its reasoning so you can audit every step. That takes the “build what you can’t buy” logic off the table.

5. They Thought This Time Would Be Different

We’ve been here before. In the 2010s, plenty of teams built their own security data lakes, SIEMs and UEBA on open-source tools like Hadoop and Elastic, convinced the new building blocks made it easy. The first version usually came together quickly. Then came years of connector upkeep, tuning, scaling and patching, often held together by one or two engineers. Many of those projects cost millions and were eventually replaced by commercial products.

AI has given almost anyone the ability to build almost anything, and the same argument is back, only faster. Vibe coding, open models and open-source agent frameworks make a prototype easier than ever, and earlier this year it was trendy to say you’d throw out Jira, Salesforce, even Microsoft, and build your own. Most of us have sobered up since. A prototype still takes days. Production still means assembling the right context for every alert, proving the output is reliable, controlling cost as volume grows, and keeping it running after the person who built it moves on.

What Building Taught Them

Some teams learned these lessons the hard way, and they make for some of the best conversations we have today. Building showed them what to look for: a platform that handles their unique use cases out of the box, not one that needs months of customizing or one that only takes the triage layer and leaves the rest to them. It showed them how much investigation depth varies, and that on the rare, hard alerts, depth decides whether reviewing an AI verdict takes longer than doing the work yourself or gives you something you can trust and act on. And it made the budget real. Once engineers, testing and upkeep were counted, they knew how much they were saving. You can learn all of this by building it yourself, or from the teams who already did.

To see how Conifers handles your own unique alerts and custom detections, book a demo.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should You Build or Buy an AI SOC?

For most teams, buying makes more sense. Building can work if you’re a large enterprise that can fund a dedicated team for years. Otherwise, the cost of engineers, testing and upkeep usually outweighs the benefit of owning it.

How Much Does It Cost to Build an AI SOC In-House?

The builds we hear about average around five AI-capable engineers plus $100,000 to $250,000 a month in tokens at enterprise volumes. Testing, model updates and integration upkeep come on top, and testing alone can run $50,000 to $100,000 a month.

Why Do In-House AI SOC Projects Stall?

Most prototypes work on routine alerts. They stall when they have to investigate unique alerts in depth, stay accurate through model changes, cope with alert floods and meet audit and governance requirements.

What Should You Look for in an AI SOC Platform?

Coverage of every alert and use case, real depth on rare and unique alerts, reasoning you can audit, accuracy that holds as models change, and pricing you can predict.

Can an AI SOC Investigate Custom Detections and Unique Alerts?

This is where Conifers stands apart: it investigates 100% of alerts across every use case, including custom detections. Whichever vendor you evaluate, ask them to investigate your own custom detections during a POC and show every hypothesis, query and piece of evidence behind the verdict.

About Eliane Limon, Senior Product Marketing Manager, Conifers

Senior product marketer building the GTM engine for an AI-native SOC platform and helping define how the market thinks about AI-driven security operations.

← Back to Resources
See it live

Watch an agent investigate a real alert.

CognitiveSOC™ runs the investigation end-to-end on top of your existing SIEM, SOAR and XDR, and shows its work.